A lot of people did like the old Bull Ring but not enough that's all. People disliked it's stark dull concrete finish, besides other things, enough to make the place unviable very quickly.
It lasted just forty years, but really by 1977, after just fifteen years, the writing was on the wall and a replacement was called for. It died a slow horrible death. It was dying for 25 years for one reason or another.
By comparison the new one is better but, the first one had all the magic, naturalness and real streetscapes that made it feel just right.
The photo of the old and new Woolworths side by side should have told them something, as it speaks volumns. The old Woolworths with it's canopy blinds is a far superior building in everyway.
Here's another pic showing a restricted view of St Martin's and, one showing a proposed brand new building superimposed in the background, beside St Martin's.
I wonder how long this new one will last?