Val I've been away from brum over 50 years, visiting UK again last year but not brum - and you are the first poster who has said to us that ''it's great to go home'' posters say the opposite, as most old homes are no longer standing, and / or are now part of an alien area, with different languages, cultures and belief systems - see this thread.
It may be that some criticise superficially, but not on this thread - we never lose the right to constructively comment on that which is our roots and was formative. We do it because those experiences have made us care in ways that being an immigrant / resident of another country never could - unless we arrived as a toddler...
So you are wrong, we have not, and and never can, lose the right to do so...rather what we shall never have, is the privilege of criticising any other country in which we live - even if we obtain its citizenship, we still do not have that right...as those who've had said status revoked have found.
trapio
Trapio. You’re right of course. However, my opinion is that if you’ve moved away, you can’t be part of the solution, that’s a privilege you get through voting and/or running for an elected position. Also, one can’t be fully informed if they’re not present.
I also left B’Ham 52 years ago, and never became an American citizen because it would have choked me to renounce my citizenship, therefore, I can’t vote here either. I am still easily identified as an immigrant as Nechells marked me with a permanent accent, and so I also keep my opinions to myself (most of the time). All this aside, I love the States, but England is where most of my family are. I love, coming home, and am just as happy to come back to the States to my children and grandchildren.
England isn’t the country of 50 years past, neither is the States, both have changed so dramatically. In fact, the entire world is completely different, and not always for the best. But so much of it is better, much, much better, and would we really go back 50 years? I’ll take Brum as it is (warts and all), and overlook the miserable parts of it, as I do those which existed 52 years ago. And good luck to those who stayed, you did a lot of it right.